The Quick Trading Profit
Your first trade almost doubled in a week. You're considering putting in a lot more money on the next trade.
Your first real trade went well, very well in fact: $300 became almost $600 in a week. It feels as if you understood straight away how it works. The obvious question: if it went so well the first time, why not put in $2,000 next time?
The problem with this thought: a single result says almost nothing about whether a decision was good or whether you were lucky. Even someone tossing a coin is sometimes right on the first try. Whether there's a method behind a result only shows over many attempts.
Going bigger after a single win confuses a one off result with a proven skill. Exactly this pattern, getting bigger after wins, is what makes the first bad trade afterwards hurt so much. If the next trade with $2,000 at stake loses just 30 percent, $600 is gone, the whole gain plus your original stake.
It's better to take the gain for what it is, a single result, and stick with the small position size you had planned. Stay there until enough trades have come together to learn something about your method.
A single result swings a lot relative to what you can expect on average. With a realistic win rate of 50 percent, a win on the first try is no surprise. It happens in half of all cases. To tell luck from a working method, you need so many trades that chance evens out. In practice that's several dozen to hundreds, recorded in a trading plan and a trading journal.
Behavioral research calls the fact that people take more risk after a win the house money effect: playing with the casino's money. Money you've just won feels less real than your own, so you take more risk with it. Then there's confirmation bias: you read the win as proof of your skill rather than as possible chance. Together this makes positions too big after a lucky streak, exactly the opposite of what a fixed position size rule would call for.
Summary
- A single result doesn't distinguish luck from skill.
- Increasing position size after one win mistakes chance for a proven ability.
- Only a sufficiently large number of documented trades shows whether a method actually works.
Did you get it?
Why isn't a single fast profit proof of skill?
Because a single result doesn't distinguish luck from skill. Only across many trades does it become clear whether a method actually works.
What's the risk of betting bigger right after a win?
Your position grows because of a single success rather than a proven method. The next loss is correspondingly bigger.
How can you tell if a method actually works?
From a sufficiently large number of trades with a documented result, not from a single hit.
What would you do?
Related
- Win Rate and Expected ValueStage 3
- Calculating Position SizeStage 3
- The Trading JournalStage 3