Not your keys, not your coins
If you don't hold the keys yourself, you don't own coins. You own the platform's promise. Several big collapses have shown what that promise is worth when it counts.
Learning objective: After this lesson you can explain why crypto on a platform carries a different risk than crypto in your own wallet.
The phrase sounds like a scene slogan, but it's a very concrete warning. If your coins sit on a platform, they usually don't belong to you legally. You have a claim against a company.
When the platform fails
As long as everything goes well, you notice nothing. You see your balance, can trade and withdraw. The difference only shows when the company gets into trouble.
Cases from the past
That has happened several times. Mt. Gox in 2014, Celsius and FTX in 2022: withdrawals were frozen, and customers suddenly had a claim in insolvency proceedings instead of their balance. Some waited years for part of their money.
The uncomfortable conclusion
The conclusion is uncomfortable, because holding your own coins takes work and doesn't forgive mistakes. You're choosing between two risks: that the company fails or that you make a mistake yourself. Both have a price, and you should decide consciously which one you pay.
Legally, everything depends on whether your coins are kept separately as your property or whether you only have a claim to have them handed over. In the second case you're an ordinary creditor in a bankruptcy and only get the share that's left for everyone. In several well known collapses that's exactly what cost customers a lot of money.
Reuse by the platform
The risk gets bigger still if the platform uses customers' coins for its own purposes, for example as collateral for loans or lending them out for interest. If a platform offers you interest on your coins, that usually means it's using your coins. There's no other way to earn interest. Interest without risk doesn't exist here either.
Holding the keys yourself
If you hold your own coins, you carry the risk alone. Lost keys, poor backups and fake websites cost people a great deal of money every year. A sensible trade off takes both dangers into account. That's why many end up splitting: small amounts for trading on a regulated platform, larger holdings in their own wallet with a backup they've actually tested once.
Summary
- Coins on a platform are a claim, not possession.
- Interest on deposited coins usually means they're being used.
- Holding your own coins swaps the company's risk for the risk of your own mistakes.
Did you get it?
What do you own when your coins sit on an exchange?
Usually a claim against the company, not the coins themselves.
What does it mean when a platform offers you interest on your coins?
That it's using your coins. Without that there'd be hardly any interest.
Which risk do you swap when you hold your own coins?
The risk of the platform failing for the risk of your own mistakes, such as lost keys or fake websites.
Check your understanding
Your task
List where your coins or balances are or would be held. For each place, mark whether the holding legally belongs to you or you only have a claim against a company, and whether the platform pays interest on it. Then decide which of the two risks you are willing to carry on purpose: that the company fails or that you make a mistake yourself.
Sources and further reading
- The US SEC charged FTX's founder in late 2022 over the platform's undisclosed diversion of customer funds, a concrete illustration of how real counterparty risk can be. View source ↗
Related
- Crypto exchange vs. brokerStage 2
- FTXCase Studies
- Wallet, private key, and seed phraseStage 2
- Matching questions for this stageQuestions