DeFi: staking, lending, liquidity pools
DeFi offers financial services through programs on a blockchain. The advertised returns either have a source you can name or come from the money of later participants.
Learning objective: After this lesson you can judge where the advertised return of a DeFi offer really comes from.
DeFi stands for financial services without a bank: lending, swapping, depositing collateral, all through programs running on a blockchain.
Staking and Lending
With staking you deposit coins as a guarantee that the network is run properly and get part of the newly created coins in return. With lending you get interest from those who borrow coins. In a liquidity pool you provide two coins for swapping and get part of the swap fees.
Where the Yield Comes From
In all three cases there's a source you can name. That's exactly what you have to ask about. If nobody can explain who earns the return, it comes from the money of the next people to pay in. In 2022 the Terra project collapsed, which had promised about 20 percent interest on a kind of dollar. Investors lost around 40 billion dollars at the time.
Risks Specific to DeFi
The risks are their own and are often underestimated: bugs in the code, losing your collateral if the network penalises you for a fault, lock up periods for withdrawals and, with a liquidity pool, a loss that doesn't exist anywhere else. That's the subject of the next lesson.
You need to keep the sources of income apart. Staking income mainly comes from new coins being issued. It's only really worth something to the extent that it redistributes the dilution of those who don't take part. So those who take part lose less of their share than they would without staking. Income from loans and swap fees, on the other hand, comes from people who are actually willing to pay for it.
Risks in Detail
The risks range from bugs in the code through manipulable price sources and keys that let individuals change the contracts afterwards, to chain risks when the same collateral is reused several times. Audit reports only cover the first point, and even that only for a particular version of the code.
Interest Paid in Project Tokens
Be especially careful with offers that pay their interest mainly in the project's own token. The displayed return then depends on that token's price, and the payouts keep bringing new tokens onto the market. That produces impressive interest figures while the token's price falls. It's the most common reason advertised and actual returns are so far apart.
Summary
- Always ask who earns the return.
- Staking income mostly comes from newly issued coins, not from real value creation.
- Interest paid in a project's own token gives high figures while the price falls.
Did you get it?
Where does staking income mainly come from?
From newly issued coins, so from a redistribution at the expense of those who don't take part.
What do audit reports cover and what not?
They check the code at a particular version, but not price sources, keys with special rights or chain risks.
Why is interest paid in a project's own token deceptive?
Because the payouts keep bringing new tokens onto the market and the interest figure stays high while the price falls.
Check your understanding
Your task
Take an advertised DeFi offer with a stated yield, for example 12 percent a year. Write one sentence on who generates this return and where the money comes from. If you cannot, mark the offer as unexplained and note which question you would ask the provider about it.
Sources and further reading
- The Financial Stability Board (FSB) names exactly these risks in its DeFi report: coding errors in smart contracts, dependence on oracles for external price data, and chained risks from collateral being reused across protocols. View source ↗
Related
- Checking a whitepaperStage 4
- Portfolio theoryStage 5
- Investing and trading are two different thingsStage 1
- Matching questions for this stageQuestions