Futures and derivatives markets
A future is a binding agreement to buy or sell something at a later date at a fixed price. Unlike with an option, both sides are obliged.
Learning objective: After this lesson you can explain how a future differs from an option.
In spring a farmer agrees to sell her wheat to a mill in autumn at a fixed price. Now both know where they stand, whatever the wheat price does until then. That's the original idea behind futures markets.
Futures Versus Options
The difference from an option matters. With an option the buyer has a right and can let it lapse. With a future both sides have an obligation. You can only get out by entering an opposite contract.
Daily Settlement
Futures are standardized and traded on exchanges. You deposit collateral, and gains and losses are settled every day. If your collateral isn't enough anymore, you have to pay in more, often on the same day.
Suitability for Retail Investors
For private investors futures are usually unsuitable. The contracts are large, and daily settlement means a constant obligation to top up. With the DAX future each index point moves €25. If the DAX is at 20,000 points, a single contract is worth €500,000, even if you only deposit a fraction of that as collateral. Anyone using futures anyway has to keep this full value in mind, not the collateral.
Futures are standardized forward contracts. Between buyer and seller stands a central counterparty, usually the exchange's clearing house. It takes on the risk that one side doesn't pay and protects itself through the deposited collateral. Daily settlement distinguishes futures from so called forwards, which are only settled at the end. Daily settlement means you always need to have enough money ready.
The Fair Price
What price is fair for a future follows from a simple thought. Instead of buying the future, you could buy the goods today and store them until the date. Then you pay interest on the money used and storage costs. So the future should cost roughly today's price plus these costs, minus a benefit you get from owning the goods yourself. If the price deviates, traders buy and sell in the futures and spot markets at the same time (arbitrage) until the gap closes.
The Benefit of Ownership
That benefit of ownership explains why, for scarce commodities, later contracts are sometimes cheaper than earlier ones. For investment products that keep renewing their contracts, the resulting roll yield is, alongside the price change, an important part of the result. You already saw this in the lesson Commodities.
Summary
- With futures both sides have an obligation and no right.
- Daily settlement means you may have to top up at any time.
- The full value of the contract counts, not the collateral deposited.
Did you get it?
How does a future differ from an option?
With an option the buyer has a right, with a future both sides are obliged.
What does daily settlement mean?
Gains and losses are settled every day, so with losses you keep having to top up collateral.
What is your risk with a future measured by?
By the full value of the contract, not by the collateral deposited.
Check your understanding
Your task
You agree to sell 100 tons of wheat in autumn at $250 per ton. In autumn the market price is $270. Calculate how many dollars less you receive compared with the market price. Then write two sentences on how the obligation of both sides in a future differs from the right of the buyer in an option.
Sources and further reading
- The U.S. CFTC defines a futures contract as a binding agreement that obligates each party to fulfill it at the agreed price, backed by margin posted as collateral. View source ↗