Maker, taker, and funding
If you trade short term, fees often decide whether your account grows or shrinks. The type of order you use determines how much you pay.
Learning objective: After this lesson you can explain why maker and taker orders cost different amounts, and you know when a post only order is worth it.
If you pay into an ETF savings plan, you rarely pay order fees. If you trade several times a day, you pay them on every entry and every exit, and that's often exactly where it's decided whether anything is left at the end of the month.
Makers and Takers
How much an order costs depends on whether it's filled immediately or waits first. A taker order takes an order already in the order book, for example a market order or a triggered stop order. A maker order places itself in the order book and waits until someone else takes it. That's a limit order that doesn't fill straight away. Whoever waits brings liquidity to the market and usually pays less for it, sometimes nothing at all.
At first glance the rates look tiny. Here's an example with a position of 2,500 US dollars and two fee rates like those common at some providers:
| Entry | Exit | Total | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Taker / taker (0.06%) | $1.50 | $1.50 | $3.00 |
| Maker / maker (0.02%) | $0.50 | $0.50 | $1.00 |
Two dollars difference per trade doesn't sound like much. If Paul trades 40 times a month, it's 80 dollars, just from his choice of order and without anything about his trades themselves changing.
Recouping Fees
Every trade first has to earn back its fees before it makes a profit. With two taker fees of 0.06 percent each, the price has to move at least 0.12 percent in your direction just for you to break even. If you're aiming for moves of 0.3 to 0.5 percent, you're giving away a quarter to two fifths of your possible profit in advance.
Many platforms offer a setting for limit orders called post only. The order is then only accepted if it really goes into the order book as a maker. If it would be filled immediately, it's rejected instead of accidentally becoming the more expensive taker order. The price: sometimes the order isn't filled at all, and the price runs off without you. But a missed trade costs you nothing, while one filled at the wrong fee does.
Stop Loss as Taker
You shouldn't trim every order to the lower fee. A stop loss is left to fill as a taker. It's supposed to trigger reliably when it counts, even if that costs more. Saving is worth it on entry and at the profit target, but not on the order that protects you from a bigger loss.
Funding on Perpetuals
Perpetuals have no expiry date. So that their price still stays close to the price of the actual market, buyers and sellers pay each other a funding rate at fixed intervals, every eight hours at many providers. If the perpetual's price is above the market price, buyers usually pay, and in the opposite case sellers do. If you're only in for a few minutes, you'll rarely notice. If you hold a position for several days, you should count funding as an ongoing fee.
Rates Change
The exact rates for maker, taker and funding vary a lot by provider, trading volume and product and change often. The numbers here show the order of magnitude, not what you'll actually pay. You'll find the binding rates in your own provider's fee table.
Summary
- Fees are charged on the full position size, not on your stake.
- Maker orders, meaning waiting limit orders, usually cost less than taker orders that fill immediately.
- With a stop loss, reliable execution comes before a low fee.
- The smaller your price target, the more of it the fees eat up.
Did you get it?
What's the difference between maker and taker?
A maker places an order in the order book and waits, a taker is filled immediately against existing orders. Makers usually pay less.
What are trading fees calculated on?
On the full position size, so with leveraged products not just on your own stake.
Should a stop loss be a waiting limit order?
No. It's supposed to be filled reliably, so you accept the higher taker fee.
Check your understanding
Your task
You trade positions of $4,000 and make 25 trades a month. Calculate the monthly fees for entry and exit, once at 0.05 percent as a taker and once at 0.02 percent as a maker. Then use the breakeven calculator to find out how far the price has to move for a trade to cover its fees in each case.
Related
- Order typesStage 2
- Spread, slippage, and liquidityStage 2
- Every fee that eats into your returnStage 2
- PerpetualsTrading
- Matching questions for this stageQuestions