Overtrading and revenge trading
Trading too often means more fees and more mistakes. The revenge trade after a loss is an especially dangerous form of it and has emptied many accounts.
Learning objective: After this lesson you'll recognize overtrading and revenge trades in yourself before they empty your account.
Every trade costs spread and fees. If you trade every day, you pay these costs hundreds of times a year. That alone turns a strategy that would otherwise break even into one that loses money.
Fatigue at the screen
Then there's your head. If you trade all the time, you sit in front of the screen all the time and get tired. Tired people decide worse, that's well researched.
The revenge trade
The revenge trade is especially dangerous. Straight back in after a loss, bigger than before, to win it back. It feels decisive and is a common way to empty an account.
A warning sign
If you notice you're trading to feel better rather than because a rule says so, stop. Right away, not after the next trade. A fixed rule helps: after two losses on the same day, you're done for today.
An example trade with made up numbers
Felix has €10,000 in his account and trades three times a day. Each trade costs him €2 in fees to buy and sell and about €3 in spread, so €5 in total.
Over 220 trading days a year that's 660 trades and €3,300 in costs. His strategy would have to earn 33 percent a year just for him to break even.
If Felix trades twice a week instead, it's about 104 trades and €520 in costs, just over 5 percent. The same strategy then has a very different chance of leaving something over at the end.
Costs grow in proportion to the number of your trades. If you turn over your whole portfolio once a month and each turnover costs 0.2 percent all in, that's about 2.4 percent a year. That eats a large part of the risk premium that stocks earn on average.
Revenge trades and growth
The revenge trade is the exact opposite of what makes an account grow over time. How much you put in should depend on your capital. After a loss you have less capital, so you should put in less. Putting in more instead combines a shrinking account with a rising stake. The danger of losing everything grows very quickly that way.
Decision quality
Studies show that decision quality drops noticeably when you're under strain for a long time without a break. That's why hard limits that apply regardless of how you feel are worth having, such as a maximum number of trades per day or a daily loss limit. If you find it hard to keep such limits over time, or trading takes up more and more room in your everyday life, take that seriously. Talk to someone about it and get support, for example from a free, anonymous helpline.
Summary
- Costs grow in proportion to the number of trades.
- After a loss your stake should go down, not up.
- If you're trading to feel better, that's your signal to stop.
Did you get it?
Why is the revenge trade the opposite of what makes an account grow?
Because your stake should depend on your capital. After a loss it should go down, not up.
How much do trading costs matter if you trade a lot?
They grow with the number of trades and can eat a large part of the usual return on stocks.
Which rule protects you on bad days?
A fixed daily loss limit or a maximum number of trades, however you feel at the moment.
What others often ask about this
How do I deal with a losing streak?
With rules set in advance: take a break after a certain number of losses and reduce your position size. A streak is normal for every strategy and no reason to increase risk.
What helps against revenge trading?
A fixed daily limit and distance from the screen. If you look for the next trade right after a loss, you're trading out of anger, not by plan.
Check your understanding
Your task
You have an account of $8,000 and trade twice a day on 220 days a year. Each trade costs $3 in fees and $2 in spread. Calculate the yearly costs and how many percent return you need just to cover them. Then write your own rule for when you stop for the day once losses pile up.
Sources and further reading
- Barber and Odean's study (2000) in The Journal of Finance, based on more than 60,000 US household brokerage accounts, found that the most active traders earned just 11.4 percent annually, far below the market's 17.9 percent. View source ↗
Related
- The one-percent ruleStage 3
- Win rate and expected valueStage 3
- LeverageStage 3
- Matching questions for this stageQuestions