Rebalancing
Rebalancing restores your original split. You sell some of what has risen and buy some of what has fallen. It's for keeping your risk under control, not for squeezing out more return.
Learning objective: After this lesson you can bring a portfolio back to its original split by rebalancing.
If you start with 70 percent stocks, after a few good years you might have 80 percent. You did nothing, and yet your risk has risen noticeably.
Back to the target mix
Rebalancing means going back to 70 percent. An example: Moritz has €12,000 in stocks and €3,000 in bonds, €15,000 in total. So stocks make up 80 percent. To get back to 70 percent, he sells €1,500 of stocks and buys bonds with it. Afterwards he has €10,500 in stocks and €4,500 in bonds. That feels wrong, because he's selling exactly what did well. That's the whole point.
Why rebalance
The purpose is keeping your risk under control. Rebalancing makes sure your portfolio is still as risky after ten years as you once decided, and no more.
How often
How often? Once a year is enough, or when a part drifts more than about five percentage points from its target. More often brings hardly anything and costs fees and possibly tax.
Without rebalancing, the weighting keeps shifting towards the investment with the higher return. Your portfolio's risk rises without you having decided it. One of the main jobs of rebalancing is therefore to hold your chosen risk.
A possible extra return
Sometimes it brings a little extra return as well. That happens with investments that return to their average after strong phases, because you then regularly buy more after declines. But the effect is small and doesn't show up in every period. If trends run in one direction for a long time, rebalancing even costs return, because you keep shrinking the stronger investment.
Two ways to do it
You can do it in two ways: on fixed dates, say every January, or whenever a deviation crosses a certain limit. Studies find hardly any difference between the two, but costs rise noticeably the more often you do it. As long as you're still paying in regularly, it's almost free. You simply put new money into the part that's currently too small and don't have to sell anything.
Summary
- Rebalancing keeps your risk the same, it doesn't bring more return.
- Once a year or at five percentage points of drift is enough.
- While you're paying in, do it with new money and save costs.
Did you get it?
What happens without rebalancing?
The weighting shifts towards the investment with the higher return, and risk rises without you wanting it to.
Does rebalancing always bring more return?
No. If trends run one way for a long time, it costs return, because the stronger investment keeps being reduced.
How do you do it cheaply?
By putting new money into the part that's currently too small instead of selling anything.
What others often ask about this
How often should I rebalance?
Once a year is usually enough. Alternatively, when an asset class drifts more than about five percentage points from its target. Doing it more often mainly costs fees and possibly taxes.
Do I have to sell to rebalance?
Not necessarily. It's often enough to direct new savings into the part that has become too small.
Check your understanding
Your task
Your portfolio holds $20,000, and the target is 60 percent stocks and 40 percent bonds. Currently $14,000 sits in stocks. Calculate the current split and how many dollars you would have to shift. Then enter your own allocation in the portfolio x-ray and decide at how many percentage points of drift you would act.
Sources and further reading
- Vanguard's overview of calendar-based versus threshold-based rebalancing shows the difference between the two approaches is small, while costs rise with frequency. View source ↗
Related
- Goal and time horizonStage 0
- What return actually meansStage 1
- Currency riskStage 2
- Matching questions for this stageQuestions