CFDs, and why regulators warn about them
A CFD is a leveraged bet on a price difference without owning the security. Providers have to state how many of their retail clients lose money, and that figure is usually 65 to 80 percent.
Learning objective: After this lesson you can explain why CFDs count as leveraged products and why regulators warn against them.
With a CFD you don't buy anything. You make a contract with a provider about who pays whom the price difference. That's where the name contract for difference comes from.
CFDs With Leverage
That sounds harmless, but it isn't, because CFDs are almost always offered with leverage. So everything from the lessons on leverage and liquidation applies, with one peculiarity: your counterparty is the provider itself.
Mandatory Loss Disclosure
A remarkable figure is in every CFD advert, because the regulator requires it. It states how many of this provider's retail clients lose money with CFDs. The figure is mostly between 65 and 80 percent, and lower for some providers.
Reading the Number Correctly
Feel free to read that twice. It isn't a critical study. It's the provider's mandatory statement about its own clients. For CFDs this disclosure is mandatory, and the figure is clear.
An example trade with made up numbers
Jonas opens a CFD on a stock index at 18,000 points. He trades €1 per point, so he moves €18,000. With 20x leverage he has to put up €900 as collateral. The spread costs him €1.20 on entry, and in this example the provider charges about €1.50 in financing every night.
If it works: After a week the index rises 300 points. Jonas is €300 ahead, and after spread and seven nights of financing about €288 is left.
If it goes wrong: The index falls 300 points, only 1.7 percent. Jonas loses €300, a third of his collateral, plus costs. If the index falls 900 points, the whole collateral is gone.
Calculations like this explain why, according to the providers' mandatory disclosures, most retail clients lose money with CFDs. More in the reality check on CFD loss rates.
CFDs aren't traded on an exchange. The provider sets the price itself, there's no central order book. So you can hardly check the spread, slippage and quality of execution from outside. If the provider takes the other side of your bet itself, there's a conflict of interest, because then your loss is its gain.
Cost Components
The costs consist of the spread, interest on the borrowed part of the position and sometimes a commission. The interest is charged for every day you hold the position. So the longer you stay in, the more you pay over time. Together these costs add up to a negative expected value. That explains the high loss rates, without having to assume clients make mistakes.
ESMA Rules
The European regulator ESMA adopted rules for retail clients in 2018. Since 2019 they have continued to apply through the national authorities, in Germany through BaFin. Leverage is capped, for example at 30 for major currency pairs, 20 for major indices and gold, 10 for other commodities, 5 for individual shares and 2 for cryptocurrencies. You can't lose more than is in your account, and the loss rate must be disclosed. That limits the worst damage but doesn't change the core problem: a product with ongoing costs and high leverage where you can't check how the price comes about.
Summary
- With a CFD you own nothing. You have a contract with the provider.
- The loss rate in the advert comes from the provider itself.
- Daily financing costs make holding longer more expensive.
Did you get it?
What do you own when you buy a CFD?
Nothing. You have a contract with the provider about paying a price difference.
Where does the loss rate in the advert come from?
From the provider itself. The regulator requires it to state the figure for its own retail clients.
What conflict of interest can there be?
If the provider holds the other side itself, your loss is its gain.
What others often ask about this
Why do people lose money so fast with CFDs?
Because of leverage. Even small price moves hit the collateral with full force. On top of that come the spread and costs for every night the position is open.
Can I lose more than I deposited with a CFD?
Retail clients in the EU have had negative balance protection since 2018. The money you deposited can still be lost completely.
Your task
In the advertising of a CFD provider, find the mandatory statement of how many retail clients lose money trading CFDs, and write down the percentage. Work out how many of 1,000 clients that is. Then use the leverage calculator to find the price move at which a CFD with leverage 30 is closed by force.
Sources and further reading
- Mandatory disclosure of retail client loss rates under the requirements of European financial regulators. View source ↗
Check your understanding
Related
- Loss rates on CFDsReality Check
- Risk-reward ratioStage 3
- Investing and trading are two different thingsStage 1
- Matching questions for this stageQuestions